NY Style Pizza by the Slice

Pizza Street Kitchen is a New York style slice shop in downtown Fernandina Beach. Walk up to the counter, point at what looks good and eat it hot, or take a whole pie home.

Slices at the counter

• Cheese, $4
• White, $4.50
• Margherita, $5
• Sicilian, $5: a thick square slice, crispy on the bottom and airy inside

Prices can change. Call 904-468-8160 if you want to check before you come.

What makes it New York style

A big, thin slice you can fold. Our dough is homemade and long fermented, and we make our own pizza sauce, fresh mozzarella and ricotta. The result is a slice that stands up in your hand instead of flopping.

Want the whole pie?

Every pizza comes as a 12 inch or 16 inch round, or as a 16x16 square Sicilian that feeds 5-8 people. Favorites include the white pie (homemade ricotta, mozzarella, garlic oil, black pepper), the Margherita, the meatball pizza with our homemade meatballs, the white tomato basil and Momma Evelyn’s (ricotta, spinach, shallots, portobello and fresh mozzarella). Toppings can go on the whole pie or on just half.

Monday pizza night

On Mondays a 16 inch cheese pizza is $12 and a 16 inch white pizza is $14. See happy hour and pizza nights.

Round out the order

Garlic knots, cheesy bread, stromboli and calzones, Caesar, Greek and house salads, and desserts like limoncello cake, tiramisu and a strawberry and Nutella crisp. Cold drinks include Mexican Coke, Jarritos and San Pellegrino.